April 15, 2014

Be the Change for Animals: Making the Decision to Shop Force-Free

Recently I read a post over at My Imperfect Dog about the pervasive presence of aversive training tools in online and brick-and-mortar pet retailers. This led me to do a lot of research of my own and to immediately begin to make changes in my consumer habits. With a sinking heart I found that I'd been promoting one major online retailer with monthly product reviews who offers page after page of  "e-collars" (a quieter way to say "shock collar") and invisible fencing alongside sickening copy that tries to make humorous light out of physical punishment. The language disguises the fact that these devices cause pain with descriptions of "harmless static" and appeases any feeling of guilt with references to "fur babies" and "parents" and "love." The more I looked, the more I found these devices everywhere, offered by almost every major pet chain, along with hundreds of reviews from customers who were satisfied with the "sweet revenge" and "attitude adjustments" that their purchases offered.
 

I read heartbreaking stories about dogs who had been trained with an invisible fence system who were terrified to leave the house, about a pair of dogs wearing remote training collars whose owner mixed up the controllers and was unknowingly shocking the crated dog instead of the dog in the field. Arguments are made that in the hands of experienced trainers and with well-adjusted dogs, these tools can be used effectively and without undue distress for the dogs. These arguments do not address the numbers of inexperienced people reaching for these tools for fearful or anxious dogs with behavior problems ranging from jumping on visitors to barking, using them without precision of timing or clarity of association, and potentially creating lasting psychological damage.


I also read some articles by "balanced trainers," those that are not opposed to using physical correction if the situation warrants it, just to see if I could be at all swayed. Whatever justification is used, I still could not imagine a scenario where I would willingly and deliberately cause pain or the fear of pain to my dog today. The science of positive reinforcement training is undeniable and its message is becoming more and more widespread. Here is an excellent explanation of why balanced training can create a spiritless or shut-down dog from the Smart Dog Blog. If you have the stomach for it, Eileen and Dogs has collected side by side video examples of dogs being trained using shock collars vs. dogs being trained using positive reinforcement. It doesn't take an expert to determine which dogs are enjoying the training sessions.

I asked my local force-free trainer - Laura McGaughey from Delightful Doggies - who has been a wonderful resource in outlining a plan for Ruby's reactivity, to provide a statement about aversive training tools, and here is what she had to say:
Electronic collars, prong collars and choke chains are tools that work using positive punishment and negative reinforcement methods. In my professional opinion, they are more harmful than helpful in training. A dog's throat is a very sensitive space, and I believe that anything strapped to a throat shouldn't be used for administering punishment or corrections. The trachea and thyroid gland can be affected, and harsh corrections can yield even worse damage; e-collars have also been shown to have a lasting psychological effect on dogs, causing them to be more anxious and fearful. Is this what we really want, when we have better options?
It is extremely important to always keep the perspective of the dog in mind, and to use the most humane tool possible for training. I believe that we should always weigh our choices carefully and put humane treatment at the forefront of how we interact with our animals. When we work with our dogs to help them make the right decisions and be reinforced, rather than coerced, we can lead happy, full lives together built on trust. And that's what makes training awesome and fun for both dog and human!

  
Another quote from Plenty in Life is Free by Kathy Sdao, resonates deeply with me:
Imagine if our primary goal for each dog-training lesson, class or consultation was to increase the comfort and joy of every creature in the room: dogs, human students and trainers.
Comfort and joy. This is what training and communication means to me, from starting my own horse to teaching a new trick to Ruby, and the heart of why I have embraced positive reinforcement training. It will come as no surprise that I am strongly opposed to the use of aversive training tools such as choke, pinch and shock collars. I don't need articles like this one to convince me. Having a sensitive dog like Ruby has made me even more aware of every training decision I make, and I would much rather exchange a currency of treats than one of threats. This puts me firmly on one side of the spectrum, and there are of course many on the opposite side who have no problem with incorporating fear, discomfort and pain into their training regimen, justifying the means to the end. Results-oriented trainers with guarantees, people who believe dogs are merely property or workers who must earn their keep. These are not the minds I set out to change, but rather those of dog owners somewhere in the middle, the new owners, the desperate owners, the ones who simply don't know and reach for a pinch collar because a big-box pet store employee suggests it (like I did years ago with my first dog), or because that's the first thing they see on the 'Training' page of an online retailer. 

Amazon UK has recently taken pinch collars off of their website and the Kennel Club UK is urging a ban on shock collars. While large corporations will not miss a handful of customers, we do have power as consumers, we do have a collective voice amplified by our spending. For my part, I will no longer be doing product reviews for any company that sells or manufactures choke, pinch or shock collars. I will write letters to retailers explaining the withdrawal of my business. I will not patronize the big-box pet stores which offer aversive collars on their shelves, instead supporting independent local businesses and smaller chains like Kriser's which promote reward-based training. 


Jessica and I have begun compiling a Pinterest board of retailers that do not carry harsh aversive training tools, and her post details the steps you can take as a consumer to vote with your shopping habits and the communications she's had with some retailers. Pet-related spending hit a record high of $56 billion in 2013 - that's billions of dollars of influence. I urge you to examine your training values and your shopping options and determine if they are in harmony. Let those retailers who choose to carry choke, pinch and shock collars know that you'll be taking your business elsewhere and why. Take the time to thank the stores that highlight treat bags and clickers in their training aisle - shop with the power of positive reinforcement

Every day I am learning more about my own training philosophy and how to articulate it, and ultimately I would hope that every person asks themselves how they can do better by their dog. Choosing where to spend my pet budget and spreading the word about these choices is just one small way that I can be the change for animals. If you'd like to join us, please grab a badge, share the #forcefreeshopping hash-tag, and help say no to aversive training tools. 

Blog the Change

This post is part of the Blog the Change for Animals Blog Hop, Powered by Linky Tools
Click here to enter your link and view this Linky Tools list...

24 comments:

  1. Fabulous post. So sincere and thought provoking. You are so right about us thinking a little more before we spend. Thanks for this post, fro me and so many others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for visiting! As I stated, I know that my pet-related spending won't make a dent in the deep pockets of the big stores, but it's more for making my own choices more harmonious. As with all these sorts of issues, if it changes one person's mind, it is worth it.

      Delete
  2. Good for you for putting your money where your heart it. I admit that I used a shock collar on Chester when he was a puppy (and I didn't know better) so I have a hard time being judgy about it/strongly picking a side.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I used a pinch collar on my first dog, Lasya. We have all made mistakes as new dog owners and that's why I think it's especially important to increase awareness as our knowledge evolves.

      If you are willing to share, can I ask what your experience was, if you thought it worked, and why you stopped using it?

      Delete
  3. I am so lucky here in my Seattle "hippie" bubble to have not one but three fabulous pet stores within walking distance that all do not carry any harsh training tools including the ever popular and always incorrectly used prong. I have actually had the pleasure of being in two out of those three stores when someone came in and asked for a prong or a muzzle. The sweet store clerk simply said "no" (not "sorry!") in one case and in another tried to engage the person about the problem and steer them in the correct, positive training direction.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It all circles back to what you want from your dog. You can get compliance to a particular behavior with force, but you can't get a truly great relationship.

    I decided early on that the single most important thing I could do for Silas was to show him that he could trust me. All the time, in every situation. I can't always do it--sometimes we get accidentally over our heads--but I try. I can't think of a faster way to ruin that than with physical coercion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've made plenty of mistakes even with Ruby - overwhelming her early on thinking I was doing the right thing for socialization, being too grabby, even petting her when she was shying away. I've had to become hyper-aware for my hyper-aware dog, and like you, ultimately I want her to trust me and feel safe.

      Delete
    2. Oh, goodness yes on the overwhelming. I basically ruined Silas for walking near the street when he was a puppy, because just as I got him willing to go out I took him all the way around the block. 3/4 of our block is really quiet, but that last one is BUSY. I can't remember that I ever got him out our front gate again. THEN, even after I knew better, I pushed him too hard going out the garage door, where he was a little happier, and ruined that, too.

      We were *not* dog people before Silas. I remember watching Turid Rugaas's video on Calming Signals fairly early on and being horrified that Silas basically spent all day, every day, politely asking us to back off.

      Delete
  5. Yep! I had a teenage employee at a big box store try to sell me a prong collar once because Moses pulled on his leash to great the kid. I wasn't sure if the kid was implying I couldn't control my dog and therefore 'needed' the collar, or what, but I looked at him like he was from outerspace and got a bit offended. Needless to say, the sale was not made. But I wonder how many other people he got to buy one? Worrisome.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really appreciate that you put a Pinterest board together of force free retailers! It makes it easier to support them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's been fun to put together - there are a lot of great little companies out there! Thanks so much for visiting, I love your blog.

      Delete
  7. Great post! I was really bummed to find out that the Easy Walk company was bought out by a radio-collar place. It's so hard to be completely conscientious, but we do the best we can. I'm just glad I bought my Easy Walks before it supported the other company! Next time I need a harness, I'll go with another brand. Thanks for doing so much leg work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Freedom Harness appears to be a stand-alone company...for now: http://www.2houndsdesign.com/Freedom-No-Pull-Harness/

      It's hard to keep up as larger companies purchase smaller ones, I was really disappointed in the Zuke's/Purina merge.

      Delete
  8. Positive reinforcement is the way to go, great article!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! I've added your blog to my reading list - did I see that you are also in Colorado?

      Delete
  9. Some of the stories that come from aversive, or even just not-positive-enough, training are stomach-turners. How awful, and such a cruel way to treat our "best friend"! We need to spread the message of the importance of positive training far and wide - and do whatever we can to affect changes. Kudos to Amazon UK and the Kennel Club UK! We need more awareness (and action!) here, and you are providing an excellent foundation for that.

    Thank you for blogging the change for animals,
    KimT
    www.btc4animals.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. The Pinterest board is an awesome idea! It's great to have a place to see where to focus our dollars so we can support businesses that line up with our beliefs.


    A.J.
    BtC4Animals.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great post. I'll admit that prior to knowing better I used a prong collar on Boomer to teach him to walk on a leash. I know better now and it's all positive training!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I used one on my first dog as well. I'm glad we can evolve with training science and move toward compassionate methods!

      Delete
  13. I know this post is a few months old, but I had to share & comment. Excellent post. I am also vehemently opposed to choke, pinch or shock collars. I'll be checking out your Pinterest board to see which retailers sell them - hope it's not my favorite one!
    Love & Biscuits,
    Cathy, Isis & Phoebe
    www.dogsluvusandweluvthem.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much for visiting, Cathy, and especially commenting on this post which is one dearest to my heart. Unfortunately, Jessica and I found out that most of the major retailers do, but I've discovered some great small companies that I would not have known about otherwise.

      Delete
  14. This is an awesome post! I shared it! :D I try to shop force free whenever possible, although sometimes I don't always manage to. We live in a pretty rural area and the closest pet store is almost an hour away. I think I have one toy from the company that was sold to Pet Safe, which sucks but I got the toy before they were sold. :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. What a great post!! I always feel like i'm trying to convince bully owners especially that their dogs don't need pinch collars etc, if they are willing to put time into quality training. UGH!! So frustrating when they refuse to try a new method. :-(

    ReplyDelete

Thanks so much for visiting The Ginger Sisters at Rubicon Days! We enjoy each and every comment and love getting to know our readers.